I forgot to mention that I saw the premiere the day after Boxing Day. I could've seen it yesterday on YTV, I suppose, but I was interested enough to download it the day after its Boxing Day premiere on Cartoon Network. (Bell ExpressVu doesn't have CN on their line-up!)
Unfortunately, I can't say I love it. But it is definitely better than the stiff-yet-sloppy CG of the last two series.
As far as Transformers cartoon series go, each later series is worse (IMO!) than the previous one (though since I gave up on Armada, I can't tell the difference between Transformers: Energon and Transformers: Cybertron, and what little I have seen I know is pretty bad). Therefore:
G1 > Beast Wars > Beast Machines > Robots In Disguise > Armada > Energon & Cybertron
If I had to fit Animated in there somewhere, it would be directly before or directly after Robots In Disguise. I'm not sure which yet.
I think the problem I have is with things like the giant bug that absorbs electronics in the premiere. Maybe if the Decepticons can keep being the main antagonists, I'll put it above RiD. Otherwise, if they spend too much time with the Angry Archer and Nanosec and these other non-Decepticon villains I'm hearing about, then I'll have to say Robots In Disguise actually one-ups it.
I realise this show is designed for kids that are new Transformers fans, but like they eventually did with Beast Wars, it would've been nice if there was at least a storyline that older fans could enjoy too, G1 homages or not. I noticed they used G1 footage at the start of this series, but I didn't feel that to have any real point.
I don't know if it was just me, but I also found a few points to be slow and dragging on longer than they should have. As I don't know where the episodes break up (since the premiere was the first three episodes combined), it almost felt like, if I had to guess, that the first episode they'd be wasting time aboard the Ark (or whatever ship they have is) and the last episode they'd just be playing catch with the Allspark with Starscream for almost the whole time. Seriously. The middle part/second act/second episode was where stuff actually happened, and if it didn't have that stupid bug, would've been the best part.